Finding a manager

You’ve heard it a thousand times: “Past performance is no indication of future results.” And that’s the spot-on truth when it comes to choosing an investment manager.

Of course we all look at past performance. Nobody wants a severely underperforming dog to run your account. But if you are choosing a manager primarily on past performance, you also should know:

  • Investment managers that outperform do not tend to stay on top over time.
  • Growth in a fund’s size can make success much harder to replicate going forward.
  • There are a range of factors other than past performance that you should consider in projecting future returns.
  • Nearly half of all fund managers don’t have skin in the game.


So what do you need to consider choosing a winner? At Covestor, we say start with the basics:

Look for an investment manager with a compelling investment process that matches your goals

Any manager you choose needs to make decisions based on a rigorous and clearly defined process – a process that you fully understand. You need to get to know their approach, their allocation discipline, and the rules they use for selling stocks (not just buying). And your manager’s approach should match your risk tolerance.

All of that is fairly easy to figure out. We provide all of those details, as well as their Risk Ratings, on a summary page for each portfolio.

Pick a consistent manager who has integrity

The manager you choose should “stick to the plan”. Your manager should be generally consistent with his or her approach, cap bias, the number of transactions typically done over a certain period, and other key aspects of his or her strategy as it’s defined on the portfolio page. Keep in mind, this type of rigidity is not going to necessarily result in higher returns. Some flexibility can be expected if you choose a very active manager, for example. But in general, you should know exactly what you will get at the time of subscribing.

Avoid excessive concentration

It’s almost certainly a very bad idea to put a large percentage of your assets in the hands of a single manager whose portfolio is not diversified. You can, however, choose from multiple managers with differing strategies and sector expertise. No matter whom you choose and in what combination, it’s best if your manager has a clearly defined allocation discipline and sticks to it. You can find those details for every Covestor portfolio, right on the portfolio page.

Fees should be low and clearly disclosed

Active management can in some circumstances help you outperform the broad indexes. But you should not have to pay excessively high fees for this service. You can choose from many different active managers at Covestor, many with annual fees as low as 0.5% of assets invested. There’s no reward for overpaying.

Beware conflicts

Quite simply, fee-only managers are best. They make money when you make money, and your interests are much more closely aligned than in the traditional commission based broker/client model. That should be the case no matter if the manager applies a fundamental, growth, long-short, market timing, technical trading, or quantitative strategy on your behalf. That is what you can expect from all of Covestor’s Portfolio Managers. And they won’t try to cross-sell you extra products, something you can pretty much expect from the financial supermarkets.

Look at risk metrics

Without getting too wonky, here are some statistics you need to know if you want to see how your investment manager really stacks up. You need to have a sense of the extra risk you are taking on relative to the extra potential reward.

It’s not perfect, but you can start with the Sharpe ratio, a measure of risk-adjusted returns. Covestor calculates this metric, as well as several other risk metrics, for each of our Portfolio Managers. No matter where you choose your active manager, you should ask for these numbers to ascertain what portion of the manager’s performance was due simply to risk exposure as opposed to security selection.

Photo Credit: Dennis Jarvis via Flickr Creative Commons